How much land does parking take? What Los Angeles measured, and India has not

A 2015 study counted 18.6 million parking spaces in Los Angeles County, covering about 14% of incorporated land and 1.4 times the area of its roads. No Indian city has a comparable count.

Benchmark note · Land use

The Los Angeles count

Mikhail Chester and colleagues, writing in the Journal of the American Planning Association (2015), estimated parking in Los Angeles County as of 2010:

  • about 18.6 million spaces: roughly 3.6 million on-street and 15 million off-street;
  • covering about 200 square miles, or 14% of incorporated county land;
  • about 1.4 times the 140 square miles given to streets and freeways;
  • about 3.3 spaces for every one of the county's 5.6 million vehicles.

Why the count mattered

Once the number existed, the debate changed. Parking could be seen as a land use in its own right, competing with housing, parks and transit, rather than as an invisible requirement.

The Indian gap

No Indian city publishes an inventory of how much land parking uses. Draft parking plans exist, such as Delhi's for Malviya Nagar (3,411 spaces recorded), but only for small areas, and they count spaces, not land.

What a city-wide count needs

  1. A consistent definition of a parking space (on-street, surface lot, basement, stilt, mechanical).
  2. Area per space, so spaces can be turned into land.
  3. A sample of wards that represents the city.
  4. Publication of the method and data, so others can check and repeat it.

This is the core method of WA Foundation's Pune Urban Land and Parking Audit.

Sources


About this note: desk research by the WA Foundation research desk, using the published sources listed above. Figures are reported as given by those sources. This is not original fieldwork and has not been externally peer reviewed. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with credit to WA Foundation.

Related in City Watch

All City Watch news →

← All publications and news