Bundled parking: when every flat buyer pays for a car space

US research found that bundling a garage space adds about 17% to rent, roughly $1,700 a year. In India, parking is almost always bundled into the price of a flat.

Benchmark note · Housing and parking

The evidence

C. J. Gabbe and Gregory Pierce (Access, 2017) estimated the cost of garage parking bundled into US rental housing:

  • about $1,700 a year per garage space for renters;
  • adding about 17% to a unit's rent.

Because the space is included whether or not the household owns a car, households without cars subsidise those with them.

Unbundling

"Unbundling" means selling or renting parking separately from the home. Buyers who do not need a space do not pay for one, and the true cost becomes visible.

The Indian situation

In most Indian housing projects, a parking space is allotted with the flat. Minimum parking rules decide how many spaces are built, and their cost is spread across all buyers. For a buyer without a car, or with a two-wheeler only, this is a cost with no benefit.

Questions for Indian policy

  1. Should RERA disclosures show the cost of parking separately from the flat?
  2. Could parking minimums be relaxed for projects that unbundle parking and sell spaces separately?
  3. Could housing societies lease surplus spaces to neighbours, creating a local market as in Japan?

Sources


About this note: desk research by the WA Foundation research desk, using the published sources listed above. Figures are reported as given by those sources. This is not original fieldwork and has not been externally peer reviewed. Free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with credit to WA Foundation.

Meanwhile in Indian cities

All City Watch news →

← All publications and news